As the MLB offseason begins to gain momentum, the chatter around the league is intensifying. Although a handful of players have already secured new contracts, the major moves that fans eagerly anticipate are yet to unfold. Among the teams poised to make headlines, the Philadelphia Phillies stand out as a franchise to monitor closely.
After a successful 2024 regular season, the Phillies entered the playoffs with high expectations, only to see their championship dreams cut short with an early exit. While they showcased considerable talent and depth throughout the season, it became apparent during their postseason run that they are still missing some critical pieces needed to secure a World Series title. The organization is now looking to address these shortcomings by making impactful moves during the offseason.
One of the Phillies’ most pressing needs is in the bullpen. While they boasted a strong lineup and solid starting rotation, the lack of reliable high-leverage relief pitching became a vulnerability, especially in clutch moments. This issue has only been exacerbated by the departure of key relievers Jeff Hoffman and Carlos Estévez to free agency. To solidify their chances of contending in 2025, Philadelphia will need to prioritize adding a top-tier closer or a dominant relief pitcher capable of handling high-pressure situations.
In light of this, a compelling trade proposal has surfaced that could be a perfect fit for the Phillies’ needs. MLB insider Jim Bowden recently outlined some trade scenarios he believes would benefit teams during the MLB Winter Meetings. One such suggestion involves the Phillies pursuing a deal with the St. Louis Cardinals to acquire Ryan Helsley, one of the league’s premier relief pitchers.
Bowden highlighted the potential synergy between the two franchises: “The Cardinals are focused on rebuilding, and the Phillies need a hard-throwing, impact reliever. Helsley, who earned the Trevor Hoffman Award as the National League’s best closer/reliever, would address a critical weakness for Philadelphia. In 2024, he posted an outstanding 2.04 ERA, recorded 49 saves, struck out 79 batters in 66 1/3 innings, and maintained a solid 3.4 K/BB ratio. His performance was instrumental for the Cardinals, and his skill set aligns perfectly with what the Phillies are seeking.”
Bowden also explored how a potential trade could include other valuable assets, such as Nolan Arenado. Although Arenado is no longer at his peak, he remains a productive player, delivering a .272 batting average with 16 home runs and 71 RBIs in the 2024 season. If packaged with Helsley, Arenado could provide the Phillies with a veteran presence and offensive depth while allowing the Cardinals to shed payroll as part of their rebuilding efforts.
However, the Cardinals would likely demand significant assets in return. While it’s unlikely the Phillies would part with their top prospects, such as pitcher Andrew Painter or third baseman Aidan Miller, Bowden speculated that third baseman Alec Bohm could be a key piece in the deal. Bohm, a promising young player, could be a cornerstone for the Cardinals as they look to reshape their roster. For the Phillies, the addition of Helsley and Arenado could provide immediate upgrades and bolster their chances of postseason success.
During the 2024 season, Helsley demonstrated his value with a dominant performance across 65 appearances. He not only achieved an impressive 7-4 record but also maintained a 1.10 WHIP and successfully converted 49 saves out of 53 opportunities. His ability to consistently deliver in high-pressure situations makes him an ideal candidate to anchor the Phillies’ bullpen.
Meanwhile, Arenado, while no longer the offensive juggernaut of his earlier career, still brings a solid bat and valuable experience. His addition could help stabilize the Phillies’ infield while contributing to their lineup with timely hitting and leadership. The combination of Helsley’s elite relief pitching and Arenado’s veteran presence would address two critical needs for Philadelphia.
This trade proposal, while speculative, represents a logical path forward for both teams. For the Cardinals, it offers an opportunity to accelerate their rebuilding process by acquiring young, controllable talent like Bohm, while for the Phillies, it addresses their immediate needs and positions them as stronger contenders in 2025.
Ultimately, whether this deal materializes remains uncertain. Trade discussions are fluid, and both teams will undoubtedly explore multiple options before finalizing any moves. However, the proposed trade highlights the kind of bold thinking that could help the Phillies take the next step toward achieving their championship aspirations. With the Winter Meetings on the horizon, the coming weeks promise to bring clarity, excitement, and perhaps the pivotal moves that shape the future of both franchises.
About The Author
Leave a Reply